Batman Zero Year started today. Perhaps an entry with your thoughts would be in order?
Huh, I would have figured Superman Unchained would be the biggest topic of conversation. I haven't gotten to either one yet as I usually read them at work on break, but you can probably pencil me in for the exact opposite of whatever Jesse Baker felt like. We can do a weekly pull list thread on Wednesdays if people want, though.
Speaking of early years, I took a shot with Wolverine Season One and man was that ever a fantastic read. Just a fun comic with Logan learning to be a civilized killer and picking out costumes and such.