Rants

2023 Doomies Results

By Scott Keith on 11 February 2024

After far too much time (mea culpa) here are the completed Doomies.

WRESTLER OF THE YEAR
Gunther (71 votes)

Maxwell Jacob Friedman (46 votes)

Rhea Ripley (31 votes)

MEN’S WRESTLER OF THE YEAR
Gunther (86 votes)

Maxwell Jacob Friedman (43 votes)

Cody Rhodes (18 votes)

WOMEN’S WRESTLER OF THE YEAR
Rhea Ripley (129 votes)

Iyo Sky (11 votes)

Becky Lynch (5 votes)

WORST WRESTLER OF THE YEAR
Tyrus (77 votes)

Chris Jericho (48 votes)

Tommy Dreamer (20 votes)

TAG TEAM OF THE YEAR
FTR (67 votes)

Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens (55 votes)

Better Than You Bay Bay (24 votes)

FEUD OF THE YEAR
Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens vs. The Bloodline (102 votes)

Swerve Strickland vs. Hangman Adam Page (30 votes)

Roman Reigns vs. Jey Uso (13 votes)

MATCH OF THE YEAR
Drew McIntyre vs. Gunther vs. Sheamus – Wrestlemania 39 (76 votes)

Rhea Ripley vs. Charlotte Flair – Wrestlemania 39 (35 votes)

Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens vs. The Usos – Wrestlemania 39 (28 votes)

BEST COMMENTATOR
Nigel McGuinness (56 votes)

Taz (50 votes)

Michael Cole (37 votes)

WORST COMMENTATOR
Kevin Patrick (56 votes)

Booker T (43 votes)

Jim Ross (42 votes)

BEST SUPERCARD
Wrestlemania 39 (75 votes)

All In (47 votes)

Forbidden Door (15 votes)

Backlash (8 votes)

WORST SUPERCARD
Crown Jewel (80 votes)
World’s End (45 votes)

SummerSlam (16 votes)

MOMENT OF THE YEAR

Sami Zayn turns on the Bloodline (84 votes)

CM Punk returns to WWE (36 votes)

Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens win at Night 1 of Wrestlemania (26 votes)

WORST MOMENT OF THE YEAR

Vince McMahon returns to WWE (110 votes)

All In backstage fight (23 votes)

Cody Rhodes loses at Wrestlemania (16 votes)

PROMOTION OF THE YEAR
WWE (96 votes)

AEW (37 votes)

Impact/TNA (12 votes)

TV SHOW OF THE YEAR
Smackdown (62 votes)

Dynamite (59 votes)

NXT (21 votes)

MOST IMPROVED
Dominik Mysterio (96 votes)

Swerve Strickland (33 votes)

LA Knight (18 votes)

BIGGEST WRESTLING NEWS STORY
Vince is removed from power (66 votes)

WWE is sold (60 votes)

CM Punk is fired from AEW and goes to WWE (22 votes)

AEW sells out Wembley (2 votes)

BLOG COLUMN OF THE YEAR
Smark Rants (79 votes)

Observer Flashbacks (55 votes)

What the World Was Watching (13 votes)

BLOG WRITER OF THE YEAR
Scott Keith (73 votes)

Tommy Hall (59 votes)

Jabroniville (17 votes)

BLOG COMMENTER OF THE YEAR
Darryl Stewart (61 votes)

Robert (40 votes)

Spaniels (26 votes)

MOST LOVED BLOG TOPIC
Vintage Wrestling (94 votes)

Live Watches (26 votes)

Fantasy Booking (21 votes)

WORST BLOG TOPIC

Tribalism (93 votes)

Politics (41 votes)

Sports (12 votes)

Thank you everybody for participating and if you have any suggestions or ideas on how to improve this process please let us know in the comments section below. For example, I pulled back the block on Scott being nominated for Blog Writer of the Year since he sold the site and wanted to make it more of a free-for-all but if you think we should move back to how it was done before, yet again, speak on the comments below.

Thanks, and here’s to another great year of wrestling and writing.